In Case You’re Wondering, This Is What He Actually Wants for Valentine’s Day (2024)

Table of Contents
BestSelf Co. Best Self Couples Game Deck BestSelf Co. Best Self Couples Game Deck The Original Cashmere Sweater The Original Cashmere Sweater Man Crates Grand Jerky Heart Man Crates Grand Jerky Heart Cozy Earth Men’s Ultra-Soft Bamboo Hoodie Cozy Earth Men’s Ultra-Soft Bamboo Hoodie Beer Drop 3-Month Craft Beer Subscription Beer Drop 3-Month Craft Beer Subscription Colsen Indoor Mini Fire Pit Colsen Indoor Mini Fire Pit GIVENCHY Gentleman Eau de Parfum Boisée 100ml GIVENCHY Gentleman Eau de Parfum Boisée 100ml UnCommon Goods Long-Distance Friendship Lamps UnCommon Goods Long-Distance Friendship Lamps Knock Knock What I Love About Us Fill-in-the-Blank Gift Journal Knock Knock What I Love About Us Fill-in-the-Blank Gift Journal West Clay Company Personalized Star Constellation Map West Clay Company Personalized Star Constellation Map Solo Stove Pi Pizza Oven Solo Stove Pi Pizza Oven My Fabulous Food Luxury Flake Sea Salt and Fleur De Sel Gift Set My Fabulous Food Luxury Flake Sea Salt and Fleur De Sel Gift Set Truff White Truffle Gift Set Truff White Truffle Gift Set Mark and Graham Watch Travel Case Mark and Graham Watch Travel Case Huckberry Waxed Canvas 6-Panel Cap Huckberry Waxed Canvas 6-Panel Cap Drinkpod Drinkpod Soda Maker Drinkpod Drinkpod Soda Maker Snake River Farms First Class Filets Pack Snake River Farms First Class Filets Pack Courant Catch:2 Classics Courant Catch:2 Classics Black Diamond Equipment Heavyweight Screentap Gloves Black Diamond Equipment Heavyweight Screentap Gloves Jeremiah and Kassy Reynolds Personalized Wine Barrel of Memories Jeremiah and Kassy Reynolds Personalized Wine Barrel of Memories
In Case You’re Wondering, This Is What He Actually Wants for Valentine’s Day (1)

Our editors handpick the products that we feature. We may earn commission from the links on this page.

Ah, Valentine's Day—a day of love, right on the heels of the holiday rush. The romantic celebration undoubtedly sneaks up quickly and is surprisingly pressure-filled. Not only do you have to come up with a unique idea for what to do with your boyfriend, hubby, or partner on the big day, choose the right outfit, find mood-setting holiday decor, and select a movie to watch if you’re staying in, but you're also expected to get a gift.

And in the rush to do it all, the resulting gift can sometimes be clichéd. Sure, your significant other isn't likely to complain about a flower delivery or a box of chocolates, but these gestures are undeniably expected. (Pro tip: If you do go down this route, pair it with a sentimental homemade card.)

To help you step up your game and avoid a cheesy gift (unless your guy is into that!) to accompany your cute love note, we’ve compiled a list of romantic gifts that guys really want for Valentine’s Day. Whether it’s the first time you’re celebrating with your boyfriend, you’re looking for something sentimental for a new (or soon-to-be) dad, you’re on the hunt for something creative for your husband (hello, DIY hot sauce kit), or you need to snag a funny, last-minute goodie for your favorite male friend, we’ve got plenty of gift ideas that are personalized, affordable, and—best of all—guaranteed to put a smile on his face.

Non-Cheesy Valentine’s Day Gifts for Your Boyfriend | 38 Last-Minute Valentine’s Day Gift Ideas That’ll Seem So Thoughtful

1

Best First Valentine’s Day Gift

BestSelf Co. Best Self Couples Game Deck

In Case You’re Wondering, This Is What He Actually Wants for Valentine’s Day (3)

1

Best First Valentine’s Day Gift

BestSelf Co. Best Self Couples Game Deck

Now 19% Off

Every relationship needs a little nudge for a bond that will bring you even closer. Gift this game that you can play together, which comes with 150 conversation prompts that help to build intimacy and strengthen your connection. Perfect for an unexpected date night or pre-sex convo to get the party started.

2

Best Cashmere Gift

The Original Cashmere Sweater

In Case You’re Wondering, This Is What He Actually Wants for Valentine’s Day (4)

2

Best Cashmere Gift

The Original Cashmere Sweater

When it comes to comfort, nothing quite achieves it like cashmere—and this one is under $100! It will surely become a regular in his wardrobe rotation. Want to make it even more personal? You can add a monogram.

3

Best Food Gift

Man Crates Grand Jerky Heart

In Case You’re Wondering, This Is What He Actually Wants for Valentine’s Day (5)

In Case You’re Wondering, This Is What He Actually Wants for Valentine’s Day (6)

3

Best Food Gift

Man Crates Grand Jerky Heart

Some say that the way to a man’s heart is through his stomach. If that sounds like your man, look no further: This heart box from Man Crates is filled with a variety of jerky for every flavor preference, including Whiskey Maple and Honey Bourbon. If you're lucky, he'll share.

Advertisem*nt - Continue Reading Below

4

Best Sweatshirt

Cozy Earth Men’s Ultra-Soft Bamboo Hoodie

In Case You’re Wondering, This Is What He Actually Wants for Valentine’s Day (7)

4

Best Sweatshirt

Cozy Earth Men’s Ultra-Soft Bamboo Hoodie

Now 20% Off

This ultra-soft hoodie by Cozy Earth is made of a buttery soft bamboo viscose fabric for a look that is equal parts cozy and stylish. Available in seven shades with over 300 reviews raving about its "super good quality" and "comfortable" material. One customer wears it almost every day—yeah, it's that soft.

5

Best Customizable Gift

Beer Drop 3-Month Craft Beer Subscription

In Case You’re Wondering, This Is What He Actually Wants for Valentine’s Day (8)

If he loves to choose his own beers or spends a long time choosing, try this subscription, customizable by month. He can pick 10 beers from five different microbreweries and receive personalized recommendations. Plus, shipping is included with all gift card purchases! If three months is too expensive, try the entry level for one month starting at $58.

6

Most Unique Valentine's Day Gift

Colsen Indoor Mini Fire Pit

In Case You’re Wondering, This Is What He Actually Wants for Valentine’s Day (9)

In Case You’re Wondering, This Is What He Actually Wants for Valentine’s Day (10)

6

Most Unique Valentine's Day Gift

Colsen Indoor Mini Fire Pit

Now 59% Off

Time to take the flames of love indoors with this sleek mini fire pit and enjoy a cozy night in. It's powered by rubbing (isopropyl) alcohol and easy to use and clean up. This fire pit might just become his new favorite hot item (after you, of course!)

Advertisem*nt - Continue Reading Below

7

Best Men's Fragrance

GIVENCHY Gentleman Eau de Parfum Boisée 100ml

In Case You’re Wondering, This Is What He Actually Wants for Valentine’s Day (11)

7

Best Men's Fragrance

GIVENCHY Gentleman Eau de Parfum Boisée 100ml

It might seem like an obvious gift, but you really can't go wrong with a luxury men's fragrance. Givenchy has been creating men's scents since 1957, and the Gentleman offering will please both his and your senses. With top notes of black pepper essence, the fragrance is balanced out with base notes of sandalwood and patchouli.

8

Best Gift for Long-Distance Relationships

UnCommon Goods Long-Distance Friendship Lamps

In Case You’re Wondering, This Is What He Actually Wants for Valentine’s Day (12)

8

Best Gift for Long-Distance Relationships

UnCommon Goods Long-Distance Friendship Lamps

Perfect for a long-distance couple. Whether you're a hopeless romantic or dating long-distance, this might be your lucky charm. When you're far apart and want him to know you're thinking of him, just touch your lamp and his will light up. It'll bring an instant smile to his face.

9

Most Romantic Valentine’s Day Gift

Knock Knock What I Love About Us Fill-in-the-Blank Gift Journal

In Case You’re Wondering, This Is What He Actually Wants for Valentine’s Day (13)

9

Most Romantic Valentine’s Day Gift

Knock Knock What I Love About Us Fill-in-the-Blank Gift Journal

This sentimental fill-in-the-blank book allows you and your partner to dote on one another. It can get as sentimental—or as steamy—as you choose. "And when your best friend is feeling down, they always have this little book to cheer them up!" said one happy shopper. Who doesn't need a little pick-me-up from time to time?

Advertisem*nt - Continue Reading Below

10

Most Sentimental Valentine’s Day Gift

West Clay Company Personalized Star Constellation Map

In Case You’re Wondering, This Is What He Actually Wants for Valentine’s Day (14)

10

Most Sentimental Valentine’s Day Gift

West Clay Company Personalized Star Constellation Map

This poster is custom-made rendering of exactly what the sky looked like the night you met, on your wedding anniversary, or during any other special occasion you want to commemorate. Reviewers love the quality of service and fast shipping. One customer enjoyed the "beautiful artwork," and another said it was a "great gift idea."

11

Best Appliance

Solo Stove Pi Pizza Oven

In Case You’re Wondering, This Is What He Actually Wants for Valentine’s Day (15)

In Case You’re Wondering, This Is What He Actually Wants for Valentine’s Day (16)

11

Best Appliance

Solo Stove Pi Pizza Oven

Create a magical evening with a date experience that includes a gift. Turn your backyard into a romantic foodie destination for Valentine’s Day with the Oprah-approved Pi Pizza Oven. Just attach it to a propane tank, and this pizza oven lets you bake restaurant-quality pies at your own house. Chef not included.

12

Best Gift Set

My Fabulous Food Luxury Flake Sea Salt and Fleur De Sel Gift Set

In Case You’re Wondering, This Is What He Actually Wants for Valentine’s Day (17)

In Case You’re Wondering, This Is What He Actually Wants for Valentine’s Day (18)

12

Best Gift Set

My Fabulous Food Luxury Flake Sea Salt and Fleur De Sel Gift Set

If your partner wants to be called "chef" whenever they're in the kitchen, this delightful fleur de sel gift set might be precisely the present they want. Inside is English Flake Sea Salt, hand-harvested French Fleur De Sel, and a golden spoon. Not to mention this set has been hand-picked by Oprah and listed in her latest Favorite Things of 2023.

Advertisem*nt - Continue Reading Below

13

Best for Home Chefs

Truff White Truffle Gift Set

In Case You’re Wondering, This Is What He Actually Wants for Valentine’s Day (19)

In Case You’re Wondering, This Is What He Actually Wants for Valentine’s Day (20)

13

Best for Home Chefs

Truff White Truffle Gift Set

Some like it hot! Selected from Oprah's Favorite Things in 2023, this white truffle hot sauce paired with truffle olive oil is the perfect combination for elevating any dish. Oprah raves, "Truff can do no wrong by me," adding that it's "so delicious." Don't wait—you might want to grab one for yourself in case he's not inclined to share.

14

Best Travel Case

Mark and Graham Watch Travel Case

In Case You’re Wondering, This Is What He Actually Wants for Valentine’s Day (21)

14

Best Travel Case

Mark and Graham Watch Travel Case

Pros
  • In Case You’re Wondering, This Is What He Actually Wants for Valentine’s Day (22)
Cons

    Tailored for the modern man with discerning taste or a passion for globetrotting, this watch carrier serves as an impeccable travel companion with lots of cushion. With seven available hues, personalize it for an extra $12.50 to elevate the experience and evoke a sense of exclusivity, making him feel truly cherished.

    15

    Best Everyday Accessory

    Huckberry Waxed Canvas 6-Panel Cap

    In Case You’re Wondering, This Is What He Actually Wants for Valentine’s Day (23)

    15

    Best Everyday Accessory

    Huckberry Waxed Canvas 6-Panel Cap

    Choose the gift that gets better with age. Upgrade his baseball cap for Valentine’s Day with this design from Huckberry. Even better? It’s made of a durable wax cotton canvas for comfortable wearing and longevity. Plus, it's available in five different shades to match his style and personality.

    Advertisem*nt - Continue Reading Below

    16

    Best Kitchen Gadget

    Drinkpod Drinkpod Soda Maker

    In Case You’re Wondering, This Is What He Actually Wants for Valentine’s Day (24)

    In Case You’re Wondering, This Is What He Actually Wants for Valentine’s Day (25)

    16

    Best Kitchen Gadget

    Drinkpod Drinkpod Soda Maker

    Now 13% Off

    The ultimate gift for the sparkling-water obsessive: This sleek carbonator is a game changer for those craving something bubbly. Plus, it reduces the amount of waste (especially if your partner goes through a lot!) and saves you both money in the long run. A worthy investment that keeps on giving.

    17

    Snake River Farms First Class Filets Pack

    In Case You’re Wondering, This Is What He Actually Wants for Valentine’s Day (26)

    17

    Snake River Farms First Class Filets Pack

    This gift comes in handy if you’re looking for an at-home Valentine’s Day date idea: Six hand-cut Wagyu filet mignon steaks will be delivered right to your front door with a Jacobsen Black Pepper–Infused Salt for added flavor. Make it extra special and prepare dinner for him with the top-quality cuts.

    18

    Best Tech Accessory

    Courant Catch:2 Classics

    In Case You’re Wondering, This Is What He Actually Wants for Valentine’s Day (27)

    18

    Best Tech Accessory

    Courant Catch:2 Classics

    Now 20% Off

    Truly for the man who loves his gadgets and then some. Take his wireless charging to the next level with this genius gift, which allows for multi-device charging all in one sleek design. Plus, you can personalize it with leather or linen materials and choose from several different shades.

    Advertisem*nt - Continue Reading Below

    19

    Black Diamond Equipment Heavyweight Screentap Gloves

    In Case You’re Wondering, This Is What He Actually Wants for Valentine’s Day (28)

    19

    Black Diamond Equipment Heavyweight Screentap Gloves

    When the air turns frigid, your man may need some extra care for his hands. Say goodbye to the hassle of sliding off gloves to text in the brittle cold air. These smartphone-friendly gloves will keep him warm while he's texting you throughout the winter season (which is always a plus!). Plus, they're unisex, so they're perfect for sharing.

    20

    Jeremiah and Kassy Reynolds Personalized Wine Barrel of Memories

    In Case You’re Wondering, This Is What He Actually Wants for Valentine’s Day (29)

    20

    Jeremiah and Kassy Reynolds Personalized Wine Barrel of Memories

    This wooden box can be customized with just about whatever you want, but we love this idea: a world map and the words "let's travel the world one cork at a time." Perfect for the couple who loves to travel—and enjoys a nice glass of wine at the end of a long day.

    In Case You’re Wondering, This Is What He Actually Wants for Valentine’s Day (30)

    Emma Sutton-Williams

    Freelancer

    Emma is a New York-based writer focused on beauty, lifestyle, and fashion. When she’s not scribbling novel ideas (pun intended), she’s off performing on Broadway and recording movie scores as a Juilliard-trained violinist. Her bylines have appeared in Rolling Stone, Parents, InStyle, Oprah Daily, and well, you get the idea.

    In Case You’re Wondering, This Is What He Actually Wants for Valentine’s Day (31)

    Aaron Radford-Wattley

    Aaron Radford-Wattley is the e-commerce and SEO Manager at Oprah Daily, where he oversees all things relating to commerce content, shopping, and search optimization. Aaron has over 15 years of experience in the media industry. Prior to joining the Oprah Daily team, he worked extensively in news media, digital marketing, fashion, and retail.

    In Case You’re Wondering, This Is What He Actually Wants for Valentine’s Day (2024)
    Top Articles
    Latest Posts
    Article information

    Author: Velia Krajcik

    Last Updated:

    Views: 6274

    Rating: 4.3 / 5 (74 voted)

    Reviews: 81% of readers found this page helpful

    Author information

    Name: Velia Krajcik

    Birthday: 1996-07-27

    Address: 520 Balistreri Mount, South Armand, OR 60528

    Phone: +466880739437

    Job: Future Retail Associate

    Hobby: Polo, Scouting, Worldbuilding, Cosplaying, Photography, Rowing, Nordic skating

    Introduction: My name is Velia Krajcik, I am a handsome, clean, lucky, gleaming, magnificent, proud, glorious person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.