Tried It Tuesday: Kings Island Blue Ice Cream Copycat Recipe - Life in Lape Haven (2024)

August 25, 2015



Tried It Tuesday: Kings Island Blue Ice Cream Copycat Recipe - Life in Lape Haven (1)

Jump to recipe

For several years, the company that Brad worked for rewarded their employees with tickets for them and their families to different special events. When we were first engaged, in fact the day after we got engaged, we had passes to Cedar Point in Sandusky, Ohio (the BEST amusem*nt park EVER). I spent the day staring at my ring, getting used to the feel of it, and answering congratulatory texts from friends and family while waiting in line to face down some epic roller coasters (Millennium Force, anyone?)

Over the next few years, we got to pick between either Cedar Point or Kings Island (since both parks are owned by the same company). When Elijah was a little over two, we decided to use our tickets for a family day and introduce him to one of the parks.

Since Kings Island was closer to home, and since we knew we’d be in the kiddie area all day (Planet Snoopy features all the Peanuts characters, and Elijah has ALWAYS loved Charlie Brown), we headed to Cincinnatti for a little getaway. We spent the morning at the park, then checked into a hotel in the afternoon so that our little guy could get a good nap before we went back to Kings Island for the evening. The next morning, after time in the pool, we headed home, taking our time and finding a few other adventures along the way.

It became an instant tradition for our family, and when Josiah was all of four months old, he enjoyed the sights and sounds of Kings Island from his stroller or being snuggled up to mommy in his carrier.

Then a couple of years ago, Brad’s company changed plans, hosting their employee outings at the zoo instead. It was still a great event, but Elijah missed our tradition.

So that year we made sure to set aside a day to visit Kings Island. Elijah even saved up his birthday money to pay for his own ticket because he REALLY wanted to go (and we were trying to teach him that if you spend a dollar here and a dollar there, you don’t get to do anything big with it).

Our boys and Snoopy
The Eiffel Tower at Sunset
Our twice-rained-on, hot, tired, but happy family
The fountains in the plaza at sunset

Having grown up in Ohio, I remember going to Kings Island when I was about Elijah’s age, and it was something special to see my little guys smiling at the fountains at the entrance and leaning way back to look up at the (replica) Eiffel Tower. With two boys big enough to enjoy the park, or at least their portion of the park, we knew it would be a wonderful day.

And it was…even when it stormed. And it did, as in thunder and lightning and downpours stormed. After hanging out in a gift shop until the rain let up, we wandered out to see what rides were open. That was when I noticed the blue ice cream.

Even though I’d been to Kings Island often in my lifetime, I’d never paid any attention to the blue ice cream sold in the park. However, a few days before this year’s trip, someone mentioned it on Facebook. So when I saw it, I was curious. What does blue ice cream taste like? Why are there so many people in line for it? Have I been missing out on something all these years???

I had to know. I suggested we have some ice cream while we waited for the rides to dry off. Hubby requires very little coaxing about that kind of thing, so that’s what we did.

One bite, and the long lines made sense: Creamy and sweet with a subtle blueberry-raspberry flavor. Yum!

We were all pleasantly surprised and immediately hooked, and it was declared that blue ice cream would become part of our Kings Island tradition from that day forward.

Raspberry & vanilla extract, pudding mix, and optional food coloring bring this ice cream its personality.
Egg yolks whisked with sugar.
Cream, milk, and remaining sugar heating up.

Only I didn’t want to wait until next year, so a few days after our trip, I was on Pinterest, looking for a copycat recipe for Kings Island’s blue ice cream, or blueberry ice cream, or Smurf ice cream (The blue ice cream was originally created in 1982, when the kiddie area was all Hanna-Barbera, and they introduced a Smurf ride – That was my favorite ride when I was a little girl).

However, if someone has a copycat recipe for this blue ice cream, they aren’t sharing it. After Pinterest, I tried Google. The only thing I learned was that there is a small ice cream shop near Cincinnatti that buys the same mix that Kings Island uses, and they serve it year-round. Nice for them, but no recipe for me.

I went back to Pinterest and pulled the recipes for any blue ice cream I could find, even though none of them said anything about Kings Island. One did mention Smurf ice cream and used raspberry extract, so that’s the one I tried.

In case you’re wondering, here’s a link to the ice cream maker that we use. (It is an affiliate link which means that at no additional cost to you, I may receive a small commission when you purchase something through the link.) —> ICE CREAM MAKER

Whisking the pudding mix and extracts into the ice cream base.
Making it blue, like a Smurf.

The first time around I followed the recipe exactly and was rewarded with a blue ice cream that tasted like Froot Loops milk. Boo. The boys liked it, but eh…not me. The lemon oil really takes over.

The second time around I left out the lemon completely, hoping that the raspberry would shine through more but still be subtle.

Now, since it had been a few weeks since we’d had the original ice cream at the park, it was hard to say for exactly sure that it’s a 100% copy of that ice cream, but it was close enough and tasty enough that my household was happy. This recipe will definitely work for us to satisfy those blue ice cream cravings until we can get back to the park each summer.

Watching the ice cream churn…and hanging on the counter.
Churn, baby, churn.
Our version of Kings Island’s Blue Ice Cream

Updated Note: If I weren’t making this to show others that it tastes like the blue ice cream at Kings Island, I would not have added any blue food coloring. It really isn’t necessary to the taste. We have since learned that our boys are sensitive to artificial food dyes (it causes behavioral changes in all of them), so we avoid them completely now.

Also, I might play around with how much raspberry extract I add the next time I make it. I’m just wondering how a little more would taste…

If blue ice cream isn’t your thing, you can always check out my recipe for homemadeVanilla Ice Cream, too. 🙂

Tried It Tuesday: Kings Island Blue Ice Cream Copycat Recipe - Life in Lape Haven (16)


  • 2 Egg Yolks
  • 1/2 cup Sugar
  • 2 cups Heavy Cream
  • 1 cup Whole Milk
  • 1 Tablespoon Instant Vanilla Pudding Mix
  • 1 teaspoon Raspberry Extract
  • 1/2 teaspoon Vanilla Extract
  • Blue Food Coloring (optional)


  1. In a small bowl, lightly beat egg yolks. Add 1/4 cup Sugar. Whisk together and set aside. (I put mine right by the stove, so it's close when I need it)
  2. In a medium saucepan, whisk together cream, milk, and remaining sugar. Heat over medium-low heat, stirring occasionally, until bubbles begin to form along the edge of the pan. (I use a candy thermometer to keep an eye on the temperature. You don't want to boil the cream or overheat the mixture. I tend to stay around 150-160 degrees, just to be safe.)
  3. Remove the cream from the heat.
  4. A spoonful at a time, add the hot cream to the egg yolks, whisking constantly. You are tempering the eggs, bringing them up to temperature slowly. If you add the cream without whisking, you risk scrambled eggs in your ice cream. Not good. Tip: I put a towel under the egg bowl to keep it still while I'm whisking with one hand and ladling with the other.
  5. Once you have added at least half of the cream to the eggs, then whisk the egg mixture into the remaining cream and return the saucepan to the heat.
  6. Heat over medium-low, stirring constantly, until the mixture comes to about 170 to 175 degrees. The mixture will coat the back of your spoon, and if you draw your finger through it, it will leave a distinct trail. Do not overheat the mixture, or you'll end up with thick custard.
  7. Pour mixture into a metal bowl and whisk in the pudding mix until combined.
  8. Whisk in the raspberry and vanilla extracts and food coloring, if using, and mix thoroughly. (You can use as much or as little food coloring to get the color you prefer. Since you use yellow yolks, the initial addition of the blue coloring will produce a more greenish blue. It still tastes yummy).
  9. Place bowl into an ice bath (a larger bowl filled with ice and water).
  10. Let mixture cool for a while (the recipe said an hour, but I did less).
  11. Pour mixture through a strainer into a bowl or dish with a lid. Straining will get out any accidental little bits of scrambled egg. (It happens sometimes.)
  12. Refrigerate for 2 hours or up to overnight.
  13. Churn the chilled custard according to your ice maker's instructions.
  14. Transfer ice cream to a bowl or container that holds at least 1 quart (I always just use the same glass bowl that I refrigerated it in). Cover and freeze for at least 3 hours to fully set to serve. (Or if you like it more "soft serve," or you're as impatient as we are, you can enjoy it earlier.)


amusem*nt park,


Blue Ice Cream,



copycat recipe,


ice cream,

Kings Island,


Get more ideas, recipes, & encouragement from this real-life momas I experience God’s faithfulness through the joy and chaos of motherhood.

Join my email list!


How We Made Our Family Vacation about a Little More

Simple Ways to Spark Joy in Your Children

How We Changed Our Family Atmosphere with One Question

Related Articles

Homemade Instant Oatmeal

May 1, 2018

Add comment

Read More

7 Simple Dishes Your Child Can Make for...

November 16, 2017


Read More

About authorView all posts Author website

Tried It Tuesday: Kings Island Blue Ice Cream Copycat Recipe - Life in Lape Haven (21)


Hi! I’m Kishona. I pour all my heart into creating a happy, Christ-centered home & haven for my sweet husband & our three little ninjas (or super heroes or Jedis…it depends on the day). I dabble in photography, concoct in the kitchen, and love sharing my adventures & the lessons I'm learning as I experience God's faithfulness through the joy & chaos of motherhood.

13 CommentsLeave a comment

  • What ice cream maker do you have/use? Also thank you for making this!!


    • Hi, Anna! I have a Cuisinart 1.5 quart ice cream maker. My hubby found a great deal on it a couple years ago on However, you can use any ice cream maker. Most would be large enough capacity for this recipe. And you’re welcome! I would say that “necessity is the mother of invention,” but not everyone thinks that ice cream is a necessity. Haha! I would disagree. 🙂 Thanks for stopping by.


      • Thank you! I would say it is a necessity as well! ?


  • What was the ice cream place called that had the blue ice cream near Cincinnati?


  • In step number 2 you said you use a candy thermometer to keep an eye on the temperature. What should the temperature be for that step? Is it the same 170 to 175 like step number 6?

    And thanks for making this-I can’t wait to get home and try this out!!


    • I’m sorry, Carolyn. That would definitely be helpful information! So, I tend to keep it around 150-160 degrees when I’m warming the milk/cream mixture, just to be safe. I know that sometimes that thermometer can be seemingly going nowhere, and then all of a sudden, you’ve scorched something. Haha. It’s basically just getting it warm enough to start tempering your eggs, but you don’t want it hot enough to cook them at that point. Hopefully this helps, and you get to enjoy some of that tasty blue ice cream soon. (Also, thanks to your question, I’ve updated my recipe to include that little detail, too.) 🙂


  • Hey! What is the shop in Cincinnati that sells it??


  • […] In previous years, he hadn’t been a big fan of even the mildest kiddie coaster, but being two years older, he tackled that one easily. He was ready to face a “real” coaster when it began raining. The downtime gave him a chance to vacillate and worry again while we enjoyed some yummy blue ice cream. […]


  • […] I do have to say, too, that having a good ice cream maker has been helpful and has encouraged me to make ice cream more often, including coming up with a copycat recipe for an Ohio summertime classic, Kings Island’s Blue Ice Cream. […]


  • Again, the blue food coloring IS NOT OPTIONAL. It is BLUE ICE CREAM for a REASON! – not angry just emphasizing the importance of the color blue in blue ice cream – your local Kings Island supervisor


    • Unfortunately, in the park, blue ice cream is no longer an option for our family since we have learned that our children are sensitive to artificial food dyes – it changes their behavior, among other things. So, one of the best things about recreating this recipe was that it now gives my boys a chance to enjoy this iconic treat again without adverse reactions. The coloring doesn’t affect the taste – just how it looks. (Natural food coloring has a tendency to add unwanted flavor and doesn’t have as vibrant of a color, so it’s just easier to skip it)


Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Tried It Tuesday: Kings Island Blue Ice Cream Copycat Recipe - Life in Lape Haven (2024)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Carmelo Roob

Last Updated:

Views: 5966

Rating: 4.4 / 5 (65 voted)

Reviews: 88% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Carmelo Roob

Birthday: 1995-01-09

Address: Apt. 915 481 Sipes Cliff, New Gonzalobury, CO 80176

Phone: +6773780339780

Job: Sales Executive

Hobby: Gaming, Jogging, Rugby, Video gaming, Handball, Ice skating, Web surfing

Introduction: My name is Carmelo Roob, I am a modern, handsome, delightful, comfortable, attractive, vast, good person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.